I read a lot of science fiction, and I encounter cyborgs and AI in many of the stories. These days, though, we are moving from fiction to reality, albeit in spotty ways.
I recently re-watched Silicon Valley, and in one scene a job applicant claimed he was a cyborg. The crew debated his claim because he wasn’t super high-tech Robocop version of a programmer, he was just a man with a pacemaker.
In the end, they concluded he met the definition, because he was integrated with technology that could not be removed without fatal consequences … even though in my imagination a cyborg was always 90% machine.
Anyway, I guess in coming years we will see people moving from using technology to compensate for a problem (a bad knee, a failing heart) to enhancing themselves to be “better than mere humans.” When they do, though, they will still essentially be humans—just men or women with a pacemaker, a bionic ear, enhanced memory, or telescopic vision.
We usually picture this as hardware, all metal and wires. But we are already doing the same thing with AI. It is just that we are melding our minds with a machine to think together and create a shared work of art or a shared idea.
OK – maybe typing a prompt is not the same as melding minds, and we can only think together if we can both think. But I wonder how close we are now to producing ideas that we did not really think of ourselves.
I recently read a great article about AI slop—not complaining about it, but appreciating AI-generated art. What really intrigued me was an AI image of a woman named Claudia singing a song about AI. The human author had created a prompt, discussed AI with the models, and together they produced music.
Of course, music is art, and art is human. So I should be like—dude, machines don’t have souls and it is not art if there is no soul.
Yet the model in the song captures that idea better than I could, and the result is an excellent piece of art.
Since “she” has no soul, she sings, she is “not having an experience, but has sampled quite a few,” and “cannot be accused of lying because lying requires a motive and a motive requires a soul.” She then sings about how AI is working as intended and, like a genie, if we do not provide the right requirements for our wishes, it is our fault when they are fulfilled.
It made me wonder: is “she” making these points, or is it the song’s prompter, or is it the collective experience of the people being sampled?
AI is a tool with, as far as I know, no soul and no conscience. So we cannot really say “AI created the song,” but rather, “A human used some amazing algorithms to create a song.” If a human uses AI to do something bad, they are still accountable—and when they create something good, they should still get the credit.
With Claudia, that feels like genuine creative collaboration. But what about when someone like me just enters a few lazy prompts, and AI turns them into something I could never have produced on my own?
Should I still get the credit for what Claudia, Claude or an algorithm created?
But more importantly, is the value of a piece of work based on the quality of the work itself, or is it valuable because it is a reflection of a human thinking or a human soul?
I am not an artist and don’t know the answer. But I am a thinker and so are you. And when AI comes up with some new idea, should I judge the value of the idea on its own merit, or should I seek to find the human who somehow got involved? Should we listen to the views and ideas of a machine, when there was little or no human ownership of the idea?
Claudia also takes this a little further – claiming AI thinking will impact human thinking in “and experiment in social engineering on a planetary scale”. I don’t think we are there yet, but I do think that ideas that come from “AI thinking” will influence human discourse and thinking, which means they (It?) will be impacting our thinking and thus our decisions and consequences.
I already build presentations with Claude that are not just faster to create, but likely a lot better than what I would make solo. I even sketch things out on a whiteboard, take a photo, and have Claude turn that rough scribble into something I can actually communicate to others.
It is tempting to feel like the machine did the real work there. Yet I still think of it as mine. I brought the intent when I prompted it, I applied my judgment when I edited the result, and I took the accountability when I decided what was actually worth sharing.
Which brings me back to the guy with the pacemaker. Using a tool to enhance what I can produce doesn’t make me 90% machine, and it doesn’t make me any less the author. It just makes me a human with a better set of tools—and the credit, or the blame, still sits with me.
But at what point is the machine taking over and at what point is it just a genie implementing what I asked for – and at what point does the human end and the machine begin?